There is confusion over what the climate "consensus" is.
There are several of them:
(1) The false claim of a 97% consensus agreeing with IPCC predictions of CAGW, based on corrupt surveys where anyone who thought there was AGW was assumed to also believe in GAGW
(2) A real survey of scientists in 2022 found 59% believed in CAGW, and
(3) A roughly 99.9% consensus (my estimate based on 26 years of climate science reading) that a greenhouse effect exists, and manmade CO2 is part of it. CO2 is otherwise known as one of the AGW variables (there are others included in AGW, such as SO2 emissions, urban heat island effects and land use albedo changes).
This consensus is NOT on whether manmade CO2 emissions pose any danger, or on how much warming more CO2 causes -- just a consensus that AGW from more CO2 is one of many climate change variables.
While a consensus can be either right or wrong, any consensus should be immediately designated as worthless if not based on data. That means (1) and (2) are worthless.
There are no CAGW data. CAGW has never happened, so there are no historical CAGW data. And there are never data for the future climate. So predictions of CAGW must be data free guesses ... while real science always requires data.
(3) is a meaningful consensus because there is a century of data to prove a greenhouse effect exists and CO2 emissions are part of it. Also, a century for non-consensus scientists to refute that consensus.
There is also a 10x range of ECS guesses, from roughly +0.5 degrees C. to +5.0 degrees C., per CO2 doubling. Such a wide range of guesses tells us no one really knows the right answer.
One can guess the ECS of CO2 using lab spectroscopy. But there is no way to determine the actual effect of CO2 in the atmosphere. To do that, you would need to know the exact effect of every climate change variable (perhaps there are 10 of them) to determine exactly what CO2 does.
The only observations possible require assuming all warming in the past was caused by CO2. Some people claimed the ECS based on that assumption was about 1.5 degrees C. That 1.5 degrees C. must assume ALL warming was caused by CO2 -- it is a worst-case estimate.
The bottom line here is that climate science has a lot of unanswered questions, along with a lot of scientists claiming they have all the answers.
It seems like "we don't know" is not an acceptable answer to any question asked of a Ph.D. scientist.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.